• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Pizzaiola

Pizzaiola is a beloved pizza brand located in North Babylon, NY, offering a wide range of Italian dishes. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, customers rave about the fresh ingredients and delicious flavors. Pizzaiola is known for their large, well-done pies that are a must-try. The owner's Italian roots shine through in the premium quality of the tomato sauce and mozzarella used. While some prefer the classic regular slice, others enjoy the unique Sicilian and Grandma's pies. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, Pizzaiola never fails to impress with its delectable menu options.

Pizzaiola: Reviews & Ratings

Maryann D.
Maryann D.

Been going to Pizzaiola for many years. Food has never disappointed. Dining in or out.

Eliana L.
Eliana L.

As soon as you walk in into Pizzaiola smells like pure yummines. I moved to Houston, TX and I crave NY's Italian food. I come to Pizzaiola every single time I am in town. The service, the food, the fresh ingredients are absolutely amazing!!!!! The best part, is that I don't feel one bit of guilt for finishing an entire meal .... BY FAR the best calories I eat and I trust me, enjoy every single bite!

Matthew F.
Matthew F.

One of the staples in me and my family's pizza places. Quick service, accommodating last minute orders. Helpful staff and nice dining area. I go here at least once a visit home.

Minah S.
Minah S.

Great, friendly atmosphere and it smells amazing around 100 ft from thr restaurant. We've ordered via Grubhub but I highly recommend picking up the order Togo. Large pie well done is a must and the the pies are huge! Know that you can freeze and reheat in the oven for a few minutes. Sauce isn't too sweet, good crispy dough and hospitable staff! Definitely, a must go if you're in the hood!

Gail B.
Gail B.

They make my favorite regular slice on the Island. The owner grew up in Italy and makes one of the best REGULAR SLICES that I have had outside of NYC. The tomato sauce and mozzarella taste so fresh and are premium in quality. The dough compliments all ingredients well. The other pizza types, like the Sicilian and the Grandma's, I do not care for.

Private U.
Private U.

Good margherita slice and vodka sauce slice with a generous amount of fresh buffalo mozzarella on each slice. The song "California Dreaming" started playing in the middle of my meal. The house/techno version from Star Trek Picard. This sadness, it never ceases.

Jeremy W.
Jeremy W.

Best pizza in the deer park area! Love the pizza here. They don't cheap out on cheese & sauce on a regular pie like a lot of other pizzerias in the area do. I get pizza all the time here & have never had a problem. I have had pizza from other pizzerias in the area. I find Pizzaiola the most consistent. High quality ingredients, excellent flavor in the pizza as well as the dishes I've tried. Very welcoming environment! From the moment you walk in the door, and breathe in that Awesome aroma, your taste buds are immediately awakened to thoughts of Fresh Italian ingredients.. and as you look at the menu, your mind wants one of everything!!! It is, in my opinion, The Royalty of Pizza! The staff and personnel from the Top down, are highly trained, with the utmost attention to detail, taste, and Award winning customer service!!! If you want a taste of New York, and The Ultimate Best Italian Pizza and Specialties on Long Island, and the Planet, then definitely hit up Pizzaiola of Deer park. Excellent food , great ownership and customer service

Location

  • Pizzaiola
    1162 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY 11703 Hotline: (631) 242-6111

Welcome to Pizzaiola, a renowned Italian pizza brand located at 1162 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY 11703. Pizzaiola offers a range of delicious options for pizza lovers, including many vegetarian options and a casual dining experience.

One of the standout features of Pizzaiola is the fresh ingredients used in their dishes, as highlighted in customer reviews. Maryann D. has been a loyal customer for many years, praising the consistently excellent food. Eliana L., a visitor from Houston, TX, raves about the amazing service and fresh ingredients that make each bite guilt-free and enjoyable. Matthew F. and Minah S. also commend the quick service, accommodating staff, and delicious well-done pies.

The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air as you enter Pizzaiola, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. Gail B. particularly praises the owner's Italian background, which translates into premium quality tomato sauce, mozzarella, and dough in every regular slice.

Whether you're dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, Pizzaiola promises a mouthwatering experience that will keep you coming back for more. Make sure to try their large pies well done and experience the perfect combination of crispy dough, flavorful sauce, and hospitable staff.

Pizzaiola is not just a pizza place; it's a destination for authentic Italian flavors and a welcoming atmosphere. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in North Babylon. Call (631) 242-6111 to make a reservation or place an order today. Buon appetito!